Friday, November 20, 2026

Big Issues With Christianity

Big Issues With Christianity 
By 
Maregaal 
Now 20, 2026


There are four notable prophecies attributed to Jesus in the Gospels that either did not come true or were fulfilled only in part. One of them in particular shows that the prophecy was manufactured after the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE. Because all the details regarding the siege and ruin of Jerusalem are remarkably accurate, yet it falls completely short when it comes to Jesus actually returning right after that destruction, it blatantly shows us that these words were put into his mouth by a later writer. You cannot be so accurate about the fall of the Temple and then fall short about your own coming.

Furthermore, when we compare the Gospels side by side, we can actually catch the later New Testament authors quietly editing these failed predictions to explain away the delay. Here are the four prophecies:

1. Returning Within the Lifetime of His Original Disciples (Matthew 16:26–28)

In Matthew 16:26–28, Jesus explicitly states that he is going to come in his Father's glory to reward each person according to what they have done, adding: "Truly I tell you, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom" (see also Mark 9:1 and Luke 9:27).

Notice the specificity of his words: "some who are standing here will not taste death." He is stating that some of his original disciples will have died before he returns, while others standing there will still be alive to see it. Yet every single one of those disciples died, and he never came back. Traditional defenders often try to rescue this verse by pointing to the Transfiguration six days later in Matthew 17:1–8, claiming that was the fulfillment. However, it makes zero sense to solemnly declare that "some standing here will not taste death" before seeing an event that is less than a week away—virtually everyone present would still be alive six days later.


2. Returning Immediately After the Temple's Destruction (Matthew 24:29–34)

In Matthew 24, after accurately describing the Roman siege of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Temple, Jesus explicitly says in verse 29 that he will return "immediately after the distress of those days"—referring directly to the destruction of the Temple. He describes the sun darkening, the stars falling, and the Son of Man appearing on the clouds of heaven, before sealing the timeframe in verse 34: "Truly I tell you, this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened."

This is the classic hallmark of vaticinium ex eventu—a "prophecy" written after the fact. Because the Gospels of Mark and Matthew were composed around or after 70 CE, the authors already knew how the siege of Jerusalem played out and could write about it with uncanny precision. They then projected their own immediate expectation onto Jesus, assuming his Second Coming would happen right on the heels of the Temple's destruction. When he still failed to return, later writers had to rewrite the script. For example, when the author of Luke copied this passage in Luke 21:24, he quietly inserted the phrase "until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" between the fall of Jerusalem and the cosmic signs, creating an open-ended, indefinite gap where Matthew originally had "immediately after."

3. Returning Within the High Priest's Lifetime (Mark 14:61–62)

During his trial before the Sanhedrin in Mark 14:61–62, the high priest Caiaphas asks Jesus if he is the Messiah. Jesus answers, "I am... And you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Mighty One and coming on the clouds of heaven."

In the original Greek, the verb translated as "you will see" (opsesthe) is second-person plural, directly addressing Caiaphas and the council members standing in front of him. Jesus was telling the high priest that he would return during his lifetime. Caiaphas and the entire Sanhedrin died without ever seeing it. Even more telling is how the later Gospel writers tampered with Mark's wording once Caiaphas was dead. When Matthew (26:64) and Luke (22:69) copied this exact scene, Matthew added "from now on," and Luke deleted the reference to "coming on the clouds" altogether—turning a failed visible return into an invisible, ongoing heavenly status that nobody could verify or disprove.


4. "Three Days and Three Nights" in the Tomb (Matthew 12:40)

The oddest failed prediction is Matthew 12:40, where Jesus invokes the sign of Jonah and declares how long he would be dead: "For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of a huge fish, so the Son of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth."

No matter how you slice it, that never happened—and it actually gets worse depending on which Gospel you read, whether it works out to three days and two nights or two days and two nights. According to the Gospels, Jesus was crucified on a Friday and buried late Friday afternoon right before the Sabbath began at sundown (Mark 15:42; Luke 23:54). By early Sunday morning—while it was still dark or just at dawn—the tomb was already found empty (Mark 16:2; John 20:1). Counting the time he was actually in the tomb gives us:
  • Nights: Friday night and Saturday night—only two nights.
  • Days: A tiny fraction of late Friday afternoon, all of Saturday, and a tiny fraction of early Sunday morning—one full day and two brief fragments.
Apologists usually try to excuse this by appealing to ancient Jewish inclusive reckoning, where any small fraction of a calendar day counts as a full day—just like how if someone is born at 11:59 PM on December 25th, it is still the 25th. While that logic might stretch to cover a vague phrase like "on the third day," it completely fails when the text explicitly demands "three days and three nights." Counting a sliver of Friday afternoon as a day does not magically create a third night. Matthew uniquely added this phrase (which does not appear in Mark or Luke) to force a parallel with the Book of Jonah, and in doing so, created a chronological claim that contradicts his own burial and resurrection timeline.


The Theological Consequence

Because of these issues, it paints a very negative picture for Jesus and all of Christianity on several levels.

First, it shows he is a false prophet, which is strictly forbidden in the Law of Moses to listen to or follow (Deuteronomy 18:20–22). Because these specific timeframes and signs failed to materialize within the generation he promised, Jesus fails the very test that Scripture lays out to distinguish true messengers from false ones.

Second, and the issue with even more gravity, is that he is not God, as Christians claim—because God does not make mistakes, and He keeps His word (Numbers 23:19; Isaiah 55:11). An omniscient God cannot predict his own return within the lifetime of his listeners, miscalculate the timeframe, and then rely on later writers to quietly edit his words to cover up the delay.

Lastly, he shall never come to gather "the elect" or his saints. The apocalyptic return promised in the Gospels was tied to a first-century generation that passed away nearly two thousand years ago. So Christians wait in vain—due to their religious conditioning and lack of knowledge of what their own texts actually say, they will keep on waiting for a return that missed its own deadline.

No comments:

Post a Comment